6 Easy Steps to a Beautiful Holiday Mantel

In this post – six easy steps to decorating your fireplace mantel for the holidays.

We’re back in the Bay Area and enjoying the beautiful fall foliage. The chilly nights and clear sunny days of fall in Northern California are my favorite time of year. I recently met up with my blogging buddy MaryJo from masterpiecesofmylife at the cutest coffee shop, Bondadoso in Walnut Creek. We made plans to share all kinds of fun things with you in the new year! Today we’re sharing two ways to decorate your mantel for the upcoming holiday season.

If you’re visiting my blog from MaryJo’s Masterpieces of My Life I’m so glad you’re here! This is the third post of our series “Styled 2 Ways.” MaryJo has creative ways to style just about anything and she has a great eye for vintage treasures. Be sure to check out her post Rustic & Refined Christmas Mantel Decor Styling. You can also find her on Pinterest | Instagram | Facebook & @masterpiecesofmylife.com.

6 Steps to Decorating a Beautiful Holiday Fireplace Mantel

Decorating your fireplace mantel for the holidays is one of the easiest ways to bring seasonal cheer into your home. A beautifully styled mantel creates a festive focal point, setting the tone for cozy gatherings and holiday memories. Here’s a step-by-step guide to help you create a stunning holiday mantel that’s both stylish and inviting!

Step 1: Pick a Theme and Color Palette

Start by choosing a theme that fits your holiday vibe. Classic Christmas, rustic winter wonderland, and coastal holiday are all great options! Once you have a theme in mind, choose a color palette. You can use traditional holiday colors like red and green. A snowy silver and white scheme is also a possibility. Even unexpected hues like navy and gold can make for a striking mantel. Sticking to 2–3 colors will create a cohesive look. For my mantel this year I decided on a simple rustic design. I chose muted colors of silver, gold, and green.

Step 2: Add Garland as a Base Layer

A lush garland provides a festive foundation. Opt for a faux pine garland, eucalyptus, or even magnolia leaves for a unique twist. You can weave in lights or ribbon to add depth and sparkle. If you prefer a more minimal look, go for a simpler strand and let the accents do the talking. For our mantel, I used an on-trend 9 foot faux Norfolk pine garland from Amazon. I am super impressed with this garland! It has a soft rubber-like texture that makes it look much more realistic. I draped it across the mantel, allowing it to cascade asymmetrically down one side for a casual look.

Step 3: Incorporate Statement Pieces

This is where your theme really comes to life! Large, eye-catching items like oversize ornaments, a mini wreath, or festive figurines create a focal point. Normally you position one or two statement pieces in the center or slightly off-center. But, we have a television directly above our mantel and it’s not going anywhere. So, I have to use shorter decorations in front of it.

I decided to make my own garland to layer on top of the faux one. To start, I combined a collection of rustic bells of various sizes and some of my vintage glass ornaments. I attached them all to thick twine using floral wire. I draped it on top of the faux garland and then arranged the bells and ornaments among the greenery. It looks beautiful! For detailed directions on how to make your own bell garland, check out my post: How to Make a Rustic Jingle Bell Garland.

Step 4: Add Smaller Accents

Layering is key to making your mantel feel full and vibrant. Use smaller ornaments, pinecones, candles, or even sprigs of holly to add interest without overwhelming the space. Place these accents in clusters around your statement pieces and garland to create dimension. To give it a polished look, vary the heights of the pieces for a natural flow. I decided to keep my display simple this year. I added some wood and metal reindeer to either side of the television. They add height to the design and help to frame the vignette.

Step 5: Incorporate Lights for Warmth

Lighting adds that magical holiday glow. String lights woven through the garland create a twinkling effect. Candle holders or battery-operated LED candles add a cozy, warm ambiance. For a more classic approach, go with pillar candles or small lanterns. A few well-placed lights can make your mantel a stunning focal point in the evenings. I had some twinkle lights I bought last year. They are 9 feet long, same as the garland, so they worked perfectly! I draped them behind the garland to illuminate it from the back. It looks beautiful at night!

Step 6: Personal Touches and Finishing Details

Lastly, add a few sentimental or personal items. Whether it’s stockings, a framed holiday card, or a small family heirloom, these touches bring warmth and character. Don’t forget to step back and make any final adjustments to balance the composition. A well-styled mantel feels both festive and personal!

Because our fireplace is off-center, the mantel is longer on one side that the other. I added some taller rustic white wooden trees to the other end of the mantel to balance the design. I also hung a twig star on the wall to fill in the area next to the television. Finally, I placed a small rustic sleigh to fill in the space between the trees and the reindeer. You may be wondering why I didn’t hang stockings on our mantel. The reason is our fireplace burns too hot. We hang our stockings on the stair rail instead.

Follow Me on Pinterest!